Live

Enron and WorldCom 2002

Accounting frauds at Enron, WorldCom and others destroyed trust in reported earnings. The S&P 500 fell 32.0% in 137 trading days, from its close on Jan 4, 2002 to the low on Jul 23, 2002: the 3rd deepest of 29 falls since 1990.

Fallβˆ’32.0%peak to low, closing prices
Length137 daystrading days, peak to low
VIX peak45.1on Aug 5, 2002
Back to the old high582 daystrading days after the low

The fall, day by day Β· % from the Jan 4, 2002 peak, to 60 trading days after the low

Timeline Β· what happened, and where the S&P 500 stood; numbers match the chart

  1. Enron files for bankruptcy22 trading days before the peak
  2. 1 The S&P 500 closes at its peakThe peak 0.0%
  3. 2 Arthur Andersen, Enron’s auditor, is convicted of obstruction of justiceDay 112 of the fall βˆ’11.6%
  4. 3 WorldCom admits it hid $3.8 billion of expensesDay 118 of the fall βˆ’16.7%
  5. 4 WorldCom files for bankruptcy, the largest in US history at the timeDay 136 of the fall βˆ’30.1%
  6. 5 The S&P 500 closes at its low, 32.0% below the peakDay 137 of the fall βˆ’32.0%
  7. 6 The Sarbanes-Oxley Act on corporate accounting becomes lawDay 142 of the fall Β· 5 trading days after the low βˆ’23.0%
  8. 7 The VIX closes at its highest of the fall: 45.1Day 146 of the fall Β· 9 trading days after the low βˆ’28.8%
  9. The S&P 500 closes back above its old peakDay 719 of the fall Β· 582 trading days after the low

Events are an editorial summary; percentages are the S&P 500’s close against the peak on that day (or the next trading day).

After the low Β· S&P 500, price only

From the Jul 23, 2002 closeS&P 500
1 month later+19.0%
3 months later+12.8%
6 months later+10.1%
12 months later+23.9%

Did the signals see it? Β· first firing vs the low, trading days

SignalTypeFirst firing
VIX β‰₯ 30panic βˆ’10 days before
VIX β‰₯ 40panic βˆ’1 days before
VIX above 3-month VIXpanic no data
Credit spread +0.5 pt in 3 monthspanic βˆ’1 days before
S&P 10% below 200-day averagepanic βˆ’21 days before
Equity put/call β‰₯ 1.0panic no data
Variance risk premium top 10%panic βˆ’133 days before
VIX 25% off a peak β‰₯ 35turn +4 days after
VIX back below 3-month VIXturn no data

A signal counts if it was first on between the peak and 15 trading days after the low. Panic signals usually fire before the low; turn signals around or after it.

The name and one-line cause are an editorial summary. The numbers come from closing prices: how this works.